FWIW-
I’ve had good luck with gloves like these:
https://www.amazon.com/Rothco-Nomex-...07&sr=8-7&th=1
They offer great tactile feedback and dexterity, are available in sizes more refined than S-M-L, and good in chilly weather.
I regularly shoot with them in winter pistol matches, or at least wear them between stages.
For truly cold weather, I wear them under mittens.
I retired from the AF 9 years ago, and still have several pair. Still haven’t found anything better for dexterity, mild protection, and mild warmth.
For those without experience with these gloves, know that it’s good to get them good and snug, and the comfort and tactile feedback improves as they break in.
My only wish is that I could find some with fingertips that work with iPhones. Magpul made some a few years ago, and they fit well, but the pads on the fingertips really don’t work very well.