Figure we need this thread, as a lot of us are old, and have memories of driving old cars.
My first car- shared with my sister in the very early 90's- was a red base model 1966 Mustang hardtop. Even with the plain vanilla straight 6 & automatic transmission, it was quite the enjoyable driving experience.
It was also cool in 1991 in a way that a 1999 Mustang isn't today.