There isn't going to be a single ideal answer for everybody on an "ideal" front sight because we each see the world through bespoke hardware. I can't tell you what works best for you.
Generally sights like the Ameriglo HD's are fairly large and have bright attention grabbing colors on the front of them so you can pick them up "quickly"...which usually means still see them if you are target focused.
That big front sight isn't going to be ideal if you are chasing X ring hits at 25 because it's too wide and that big yellow ball that works great when you're target focused at 5 is going to be a distraction from seeing the very tip of the front sight.
Something like the JohnO front sight modification on a good set of sights like Heinies or Dawsons is a good compromise between the need for visibility and precision:
https://pistol-training.com/articles...y-front-sight/