I guess I'm lost here... What is your point exactly? What are the negatives of the Maratac?
What I want from it is a cheap watch that looks nice and has that particular look (tool watch, dive watch, casual watch) and the SR-1/9051L seems to have a solid blend of that and is priced very well for a clean looking watch. I can't think of a decent alternative that has all that for less. If there is lemme know. They're not purported to be anything else and there aren't any claims that are false, that I can find.
The next closest thing would be a modded Seiko and I can't click and have one in a few days. I also really like the case on the Maratac compared to some of the Seiko's.