For winter I just train to take off the drawing hand glove when my SA starts to tingle or rip it off and drop it just B4 I draw if the situation turns bad real fast. Its so much easier and cheaper than trying to find gloves or draw with thicker winter gloves. I would rather reduce variables than add one more to the equation...
What’s the intended purpose of the gloves (primary use), how long will you be wearing them while carrying?
For example - traveling through an urban area using public transit all day, or using them to brush snow off your car and then to pump gas, jogging/active walking for exercise, hanging out at the local sledding hill w/ your family, wearing them in a suit/buisness attire?
Gloves are tools, right tool for the right job while understanding its limitations. Living in Alaska I have quite a few pair. If I’m moving through transitional spaces, parking lots, gas stations, etc - I don’t wear any and keep my hands warm in my coat pockets.
My personal preference is to wear an easily removable gauntlet style glove vs something tight.
If the gloves I’m wearing are bulky - that variable goes into my OODA loop.
If I had to wear dressier suit/business gloves I’d definitely make sure I can get a good grip and trigger finger fits in the trigger guard. Maybe something with thin wool or wind stopper fabric and leather palm…ala arxteryx, Patagonia, OR, etc, the winter golf gloves look interesting, or a winter set of Newmans (football gloves) if they’re still made.
The absolute best gloves I've found for general-purpose cold wet weather is military D3A leather shell gloves with the olive drab wool liner gloves.
The leather protects hands from windchill and the wool liner gloves keep your hands warm when wet.
I like them because if I have to take the gloves off and on throughout the day, they don't stick to my hands and turn inside out when you take them off, and they aren't difficult to remove, unlike many other gloves.
The 95% answer is Outdoor Research.
As was described earlier, gloves are tools. OR is the SnapOn Tools of gloves. And you pay for that.
Generally I have a liner glove and heavier over gloves for extended outside wear.
For normal running around town, their Storm Tracker gloves are my main wear. You can manipulate a pistol or rifle in them, but your hands will eventually get cold.
Prior to going with OR, I used the Kangaroo Leather gloves from Cabelas. Decent fit, decent ability to manipulate and durable but you will also get cold over time. Before that, I used numerous types of winter golf gloves, and I still a keep a well worn pair in my shooting bag.