While I think a carbine class will increase overall skill and confidence with the carbine, I’m not sure it will translate directly to better performance on the qual course. Most carbine classes emphasize manipulations and closer distances - and often that’s a limitation of a commercial range.
In my (admittedly dated) opinion, much of the problem with the qual course is tied to the 25M zero, which is suboptimal and contributes to shooting over mid range targets. Take a course with any notable instructor who covers zero and I suspect you’ll leave with a 50 or 100 zero. Understanding how the zero affects the mid range targets can help - I doubt the Army is covering this in Basic.
You can also learn the qual course sequence- it doesn’t change (at least it hadn’t - again it’s been a while) - it’s in the manual. So you’ll spend less time scanning for targets if you know what’s next. We used to set up a dry fire course with canteens to simulate the pop up target placement and call out the sequence.
I do understand that a new qual is rolling out but I’m not sure how quickly.
I still think a class is a smart investment but I’d look at the curriculum and venue.
Last edited by JSGlock34; 03-25-2023 at 08:42 AM.
"When the phone rang, Parker was in the garage, killing a man."
The new Qual (-40) has been in use for 2 years and has been the standard at BCT and unit qualifications.
Paper qual (Alt-C) is no longer used except for validation when a qual range is not possible.
I have found that this is image is helpful for Soldiers to visualize their POA for hold unders with a 300m zero:
Ideally we should all qual with optics and irons but given the limitations of ammunition, the reality is, at least non combat arms folks, you will only qualify on one of them.
This video is one we put up on a big projector for Soldiers to run through the sequence of fire:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q_GrVjnrkOM
Thanks - great pic and illustrates exactly what I’m getting at. With the 25/300M zero you can have a POA/POI deviation of nearly a foot on some of the mid range targets, which means if you are aiming upper center mass, you are actually landing shots on the head or shooting over. Knowing your hold unders can make a real difference since so many of the targets are in that 150-200M range.
I took a carbine class with Vickers - geez over a decade ago - and he had us zero at 100. His view was he wanted to eliminate hold unders completely. I probably shot the furthest with Ernest Langdon; he had us zero at 50. Unfortunately, you don’t get to pick your zero in the conventional force.
"When the phone rang, Parker was in the garage, killing a man."
Very important feedback in this re the new qual.
No alibis and no stops once the qual starts. The Soldier has to be more fluid with gunhandling skills and moving through the positions. Quite different than the old qual. No alibis. Once the time starts the Soldier has to move through the positions and execute unprompted reloads etc.
“Remember, being healthy is basically just dying as slowly as possible,” Ricky Gervais
So just a question how reasonable would it be to practice with scaled targets and a S&W 15-22?
I'll wager you a PF dollar™ 😎
The lunatics are running the asylum
You could buy Alt-C targets and practice those…but I think that’ll just get you better at…Alt-C. But I do exactly this with my son from time to time (shoot Alt-C with a 15-22). It’s fun - he likes shooting for score.
Given Yute’s point about being able to shoot a good zero, I’d start there with the military zero target at 25. Make sure the fundamentals are sound.
"When the phone rang, Parker was in the garage, killing a man."
I actually do this - helpful this particularly if you can work your speed reloads and your transitions on the range. I use the Alt-c target (https://shop.actiontarget.com/conten...ion-target.asp) with a Tippmann Arms M4-22 (I have a M&P 15-22 but vastly prefer the Tippmann Arms rifle).
I run the target at 25 yards.
Only thing the target doesn’t do is show hold unders well.
The sequence of fire is in the TC manual so it helps to have a buddy shout out the target to hit, e.g. right 300m.
What’s interesting is that the old M16a1 alt-c target seems to have hold unders built in, but I’ve never found the source to support that or history of the target.
https://www.grainger.com/product/ACT...ed-Fire-48FT25