Yea but…
There are times when going against conventional wisdom makes sense for an individual due to individual needs. One of my employees just bought a house. Everyone says she’s an idiot to buy right now, except that her rent nearly doubled and her mortgage is about what her old rent was.
Forgoing credit cards may cost you in terms of built-in credit card fees with pricing, losing out on rewards, and generally making people behind you in line at the grocery store want to stab you to death with an altoids tin (if the teenage cashier doesn’t murder you with her glare and sarcasm first), but if that’s what it takes to keep from over-spending then it may save someone money in the long run.
A guy I know at work literally puts cash into envelopes for various budgets so his stay at-home wife keeps them within their means. Envelope for groceries, envelope for entertainment, etc.
Many years ago, when I was finishing grad school, most of my friends had graduated and moved away, and the internet and internet shopping was becoming a thing, I got myself into some credit card debt. Leaving grad school and making $42k/year then made me feel like a millionaire, which meant I wasn’t interested in doing much to pay it down. IIRC the nut eventually got to be around $10k. One of the problems I had was that I had memorized my credit card number, and as such it was super easy to just type it in and get a new crescent wrench, or Harley muffler, or holster… eventually I had them re-issue a new card with a new number (told them the old one was lost) and managed to keep myself from memorizing it.
Of course now they’ve hacked that hack and they’re happy to store you information to make future check out easier. Which always seems like a good idea at the time.
My wife grew up “spoiled”. Whatever she wanted or needed, her dad got her and then some. Almost any family trip they went on, her and her brother each brought a friend. There was always more than one hotel room involved. AFAIK nobody had an allowance because you simply had to ask and the new thing showed up. My brother and I never took a friend on vacation, the whole family always stayed in one room, often the “vacations” were to go visit family somewhere, we both got allowance and were limited to pretty much that, and even our Xmas and birthday gifts had a stated dollar limit.
I tend to over-shop. I’m better off than my parents were, I grew up “wanting” and also “comparing” to the other kids and families that got or had more than we did. For someone like me, the temptation of the latest YouTube video combined with the means to obtain just about whatever I want plus an “optimizer” (vs “saticficer”) personality has me constantly “shopping” even when I don’t realize it.
I think that spending is like dieting. You have to allow for some amount of fun in the here and now. Our financial adviser tells us we are on-track for our goals based on our current investment situation and future plan. To me, that means that my “budget” needs to mean simply “pay off everything at the end of every month without dipping into savings”. If I over-spend in July buying a new planer for the shop, then I need to tighten it up a bit in August. We keep enough “cash” in hand to allow for that ebb and flow.
I also think that it helps to be self-aware, and also to keep an eye out for the signs. When I learned to ride a motorcycle they said “ride with the mentality that everyone in a car is trying to kill you”. I try to think the same way about the internet, YouTube, etc. sites like arfcom (and even this one) may not exist express.y to sell you one product or another, but they have sponsors, and at some level there is a desire by someone to sell you something. No individual member starts a “fans of Spyderco” thread to try and sell more knives, but the ‘knife center” sponsor sure ain’t mad about it. It helps to keep those things in mind when browsing. Otherwise, like me, you wind up with two new Salt series (plus a Microtech from another thread) all in the single month your wife and kids are out of town…