The recent post about the durability of the K6 had me wondering just how our resident round gun experts would rank the current run of production revolvers.

So, how would you list them by make & model in general terms of reliability, fit & finish, accuracy, and so on?

And to keep the oranges with oranges, apples with apples, let's split it into "Service sized .357" (general 6 shot, 3-4" barrel), and "Carry sized .38" (5 shot 2" barrel).