I’m a fan of the non-finger-grooved Hogue. I don’t like it more than the Compact Lett though. Different grips for different purposes. I’m not a fan of anything but rubber on the GP. Loses the main benefit of that grip stud arrangement. I like my hand being insulated from anything hard and unforgiving while shooting hot magnum loads.
Nothing so needs reforming as other people's habits - Mark Twain
Tact is the knack of making a point without making an enemy / Where is the wisdom we have lost in knowledge?
Question has been answered a few times, so I'm just adding my opinion. I think the half lug 6-inch guns look a little like the slack-jawed yokel characters on The Simpsons. Four inch half-lugs are better, but the Lipsey's 5-inch is, IMO, the best looking GP ever made. Nonetheless, I recently sent mine down the road for most excellent reasons.
I might, however, one day still make a slim-lug GP. I could probably be talked into it as a .327 Federal launcher. The inside-radius cutter I bought for the mill is just sitting in the drawer, not doing anything, and a heavy, 6-inch gun would be a pretty good .327 launcher.
.
-----------------------------------------
Not another dime.
I remember holding a similar gun in a pawn shop 25 years ago. I remember it having the compact grips and it fitting like a glove. The gun was one of the best feeling revolvers and incredibly balanced.
I have a 6" inch 1/3 lug Security Six I picked up a couple of years ago for $300. The only thing I have shot out of it is Cowboy fastdraw wax bullets. I shoot my 3 or 4 inch guns a lot more.
HiTS Revolver Super Test I shot with it on my first outing with it. That one in the 8 rings was a real bummer.