Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 123 LastLast
Results 11 to 20 of 28

Thread: FORD DEALERS LACK OF SERVICE ON OLDER VEHICLES ?

  1. #11
    Site Supporter
    Join Date
    Oct 2012
    Location
    USA
    Quote Originally Posted by JRB View Post
    Vehicles 10+ years old should be considered enthusiast vehicles and dealership ability and skill for maintaining/repairing them should be heavily scrutinized.
    From my time spent as a flat-rate dealer tech, I agree with this sentence wholeheartedly.

    My vehicles mostly date from the period 2000-2004 because it's the time that I was a tech, and I understand their systems thoroughly. I also can still get paper copies of shop manuals for them off ebay, which is what I was used to and is what I still prefer.

  2. #12
    Glock Collective Assimile Suvorov's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Location
    Escapee from the SF Bay Area now living on the Front Range of Colorado.
    Quote Originally Posted by JRB View Post
    03 Cobra? Niiiice.


    Long story short, the 6.8L V10 hasn't been offered in common passenger vehicles since 2005.
    Like every auto maker these days, attrition/turnover/etc with service techs is worse than it has ever been. So that dealership is likely doing you a favor because it's likely they have maybe one or two guys in that whole service department with any kind of formal training on servicing the 6.8L V10. Or an Excursion of any powertrain, for that matter.

    I'd say it's equally likely that not a single tech in that whole workshop has formal training on either, and they'd be dependent on factory documentation and 'figuring it out' to actually do real work on it. Which screws flag hour technicians in a big way (nobody wants to spend 15 hours getting a 5 hour job done right for the first time that they'll likely never do again, and only get paid for that 5 hours) and also screws the service writer because that 'figure it out' time is time lost for that tech to get something else done that they know 100%.
    Add parts availability to the mix, and the high chance that whatever part(s) needs to be replaced is no longer available as a Ford Genuine part, and thereby impossible for a dealership to replace, it all adds up to a shit sandwich nobody wants to eat.

    So given the high likelihood of a rushed job by a tech that doesn't truly know that V10, and the corresponding high likelihood parts being impossible to find, or a botched repair resulting in a bringback and pissed off customer - it's cheaper in time and money for everyone to annoy you, the customer, up front by simply just skipping the job entirely.

    To reiterate, this is an issue across older models from literally every brand selling vehicles in the US these days. Vehicles 10+ years old should be considered enthusiast vehicles and dealership ability and skill for maintaining/repairing them should be heavily scrutinized.

    If you're not interested in a newer vehicle, I'd find a local diesel shop that does lots of work on old 7.3L Powerstrokes and such, and ask them about working on your Excursion.



    Not what I’m wanting to hear as I have a ‘98 Cobra that may be needing some engine work. It seems real hard to find shops in the bay that know much about late model mustangs and I was hoping a SVT dealership would know what needs done.

  3. #13
    Quote Originally Posted by Coyotesfan97 View Post
    I recently had a camshaft position sensor CEL crop up on my 05 Jeep Wrangler. The easy fix is a new one. Chrysler/Dodge no longer makes the part so no OEM and you’re rolling the dice on new parts. Jeep forum guys recommend getting a used one from a wrecking yard.
    Seems to me like they probably never made something like that in house anyway, wonder if there might be a way to figure out who they sourced it to and seek out that brand?

  4. #14
    Site Supporter Coyotesfan97's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Location
    Phoenix Metro, AZ
    Quote Originally Posted by mmc45414 View Post
    Seems to me like they probably never made something like that in house anyway, wonder if there might be a way to figure out who they sourced it to and seek out that brand?
    Not anyway I could tell and I read a lot about this on two Jeep forums.
    Just a dog chauffeur that used to hold the dumb end of the leash.

  5. #15
    Site Supporter
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Location
    ABQ, NM
    Quote Originally Posted by trailrunner View Post
    I never really understood charging the book value, or a flat rate, for each repair. Seems like it inflates the price, because as I understand it, a good mechanic can usually do a repair much faster (I can even do some repairs faster than the book rate, and I'm an amateur). Is this correct?
    That was the original intent of 'book time' - accommodate techs still learning, prevent the shop from paying a tech taking things slow for no reason, but allow a true expert to get ahead. How it works in practice is now very different. In all of my years working on flag hours aka 'book time' I hit 40 flag hours in a week for 40 hours worked exactly once, ever. Almost always, billed hours was 25-35hrs for every 40 hours I actually worked.

    These days, on almost any modern vehicle it takes a true expert with the exact right tools and absolutely no parts delays to even match book time on a majority of jobs. The more complicated the job, the less likely the tech will make book on it. The 'gravy' jobs, aka the jobs that you can almost always complete under book time, are rarer and rarer across every brand.
    This means that if you get charged, say, 50 hours labor to replace a full engine assembly - you can pretty much bet that the tech will have 65-80 hours in the actual job.
    Older, simpler vehicles were much easier in all regards, including book time.

    Quote Originally Posted by trailrunner View Post
    Overall, this is another reason I really hate dealers. I fully and completely understand that they want to make a profit, but sometimes in business there will be some losing jobs. If he bought 5 cars from the dealership and has been bringing them in over the last 20-25 years for routine things like oil changes, they've made a decent profit on all the other jobs. Not only give the tech a break, give him a reward for figuring it out (OK, I'm a little naive). A company like Ford that has been in business for a century should stand behind their product and fix the truck.

    This is just my opinion and another reason I despise dealerships and go to my local garage. They specifically advertise that they will keep your older car running because it's cheaper than buying a new car. Two of my cars are 19 and 17 years old and they've never had problems getting parts. My old truck was 25 years old and they also kept that running for me until it rusted out.
    Get Sig to work on 556IX. Or get Apple to repair an iPhone 4S. They don't because they don't have to. Just because they made it doesn't mean they have to work on it. This is no different with cars. It is a consumer product.
    Once the warranty period is up, the OE makes little if anything on vehicles that last forever. The only benefit to making a vehicle that lasts forever, like a Toyota, is that it drives new vehicle sales by reputation. Toyota, Mercedes, and a few other makers are pretty good about enduring genuine parts for common engines/vehicles that were made by the hundreds of thousands. Others like Ford are not. But getting upset about a lack of parts or experienced service techs for a vehicle and engine that were both discontinued 17 years ago now -using the 2005 V10 Excursion as an example- is pretty silly.
    I've been personally involved in trying to get Toyota to reproduce a lot of desirable original parts for the 1993-1998 Supra and Toyota doesn't give a tenth-inch of shit about parts for old Supras - they'll sell 100 Priuses in two weeks and make more money doing that and not have to do a damn thing... but that's a rant for another time.


    Quote Originally Posted by AKDoug View Post
    ...I would never take a car out of warranty to a dealership. By the time a vehicle is over 6 years old, the advantage of using the dealer is gone and a good independent shop has seen enough of them to keep current and do a good job.
    Emphatically agreed - it is best to find a shop that is set up for and genuinely loves working on the vehicle you have. They'll have all the right tools, tricks, know which parts are the best from a list of suppliers, have faster & more skilled diagnostic abilities, etc. That makes all the difference.

    Quote Originally Posted by Suvorov View Post
    Not what I’m wanting to hear as I have a ‘98 Cobra that may be needing some engine work. It seems real hard to find shops in the bay that know much about late model mustangs and I was hoping a SVT dealership would know what needs done.
    Unfortunately, the majority of dealerships are a bunch of fucking idiots about higher end sports cars available within the brand. I worked on a LOT of SVT's, GT500's, even a couple of Ford GT's because the owners did not trust our local Ford dealer or their staff with their vehicles. I can't blame them.
    The older it gets and the rarer it gets, the less and less likely anyone in that shop will know WTF they're doing on a car like that.

    The '96 and '98 SVT Cobras were rare ponies to begin with and they're VERY rare now. Find the local Mustang people and find their favorite hole in the wall garage ran by a guy that eats, lives, and breathes Ford mod motors and SN95/New Edge Mustangs, and that will be the right place. I can almost guarantee he'll have a wait list months long.

    In the meantime, I've had my head in the tight ass engine bay of several SN95 Cobras over the years, and I've damn near bought one on at least 3 different occasions. So feel free to drop me a PM if you have any pressing questions/issues I might be able to help you figure out!

  6. #16
    Site Supporter Palmguy's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2012
    Location
    NW Florida
    Quote Originally Posted by JRB View Post
    Unfortunately, the majority of dealerships are a bunch of fucking idiots about higher end sports cars available within the brand. I worked on a LOT of SVT's, GT500's, even a couple of Ford GT's because the owners did not trust our local Ford dealer or their staff with their vehicles. I can't blame them.
    The older it gets and the rarer it gets, the less and less likely anyone in that shop will know WTF they're doing on a car like that.

    The '96 and '98 SVT Cobras were rare ponies to begin with and they're VERY rare now. Find the local Mustang people and find their favorite hole in the wall garage ran by a guy that eats, lives, and breathes Ford mod motors and SN95/New Edge Mustangs, and that will be the right place. I can almost guarantee he'll have a wait list months long.

    In the meantime, I've had my head in the tight ass engine bay of several SN95 Cobras over the years, and I've damn near bought one on at least 3 different occasions. So feel free to drop me a PM if you have any pressing questions/issues I might be able to help you figure out!
    Certainly true that there never were that many 96-98 Cobras running around....but Ford did make a trillion 4.6s (and 5.4s) so depending on the issue he might be better off than the OP. The top end is where that engine is pretty exclusive; the heads and intake manifold changed pretty substantially in '99. Totally agree on the advice, to add to that, check the Mustang forums and you'll probably find good guidance.

    I've had more mod motors than I can immediately recall, and have some pretty good resources - my dad spent his life running a Ford service department and has a '96 Cobra. Feel free to reach out to me as well and I'll do what I can to help.

  7. #17
    Not my lane in any way however: to at least get some idea what the MIL means you can get either code scanners or Forscan and an inexpensive DLC dongle, then do some research online. This may not even require opening the hood, the investment is pretty cheap especially for Forscan which is free.

    If the diagnosis / code is complicated and expensive this may at least inform how to proceed with further efforts to find a place to repair it. There are a surprising number of videos & blogs out that that reference pretty specific DTC codes. Your vehicles are not that common but the V10 was also used in F250, F350 and possibly other Super Duty trucks.

    Sucks that dealers and Ford itself are not interested in supporting the vehicles they were happy to sell you, but previous posts have pretty much covered that disgraceful situation.

  8. #18
    Site Supporter
    Join Date
    Oct 2012
    Location
    USA
    I think the industry must have turned on it's ear since I was in.

    Quote Originally Posted by farscott View Post
    It is also important to remember that a dealer can make the most money on warranty repairs as Ford pays the book rate for the job as well as for the part.
    We *hated* warranty work because while yes, there was a flag time attached to it, it was almost impossible to match. Daimler-Chrysler figured warranty paid time starting with the vehicle in the bay, on the lift if necessary, parts in hand, and necessary tools already out. Multiple practice runs had already been made.

    A tech of average experience could expect the job to take about twice the flag time. As technicians, a job where we could match warranty paid time was a day to celebrate. Recalls were figured the same way. For example, there was a limited recall on the automatic trans breather vent on the Dakota back around '00 or '01 which the repair process included unbolting a bunch of stuff including body mounts and jacking the cab up so you could reach the affected area. If I remember, it paid 1.6 hours which was nowhere close to how long it actually took to do. I figured out a way to reach around the back of the engine and do the job in 0.3. It was a rare case of getting one over on the factory. So I got all of those recalls that came in the door.

    Quote Originally Posted by JRB View Post
    In all of my years working on flag hours aka 'book time' I hit 40 flag hours in a week for 40 hours worked exactly once, ever. Almost always, billed hours was 25-35hrs for every 40 hours I actually worked....


    This means that if you get charged, say, 50 hours labor to replace a full engine assembly - you can pretty much bet that the tech will have 65-80 hours in the actual job.
    50 HOURS?!?!?! Wow, things have certainly changed. An engine replacement used to be 17-25 hours. The most recent engine I've replaced was on a '13 Prius and even slowing way down and taking my time because it was for a personal friend, it still took less than 15. If I'd done another back-to-back I'm not sure it would've taken much over half that. No belts or engine-mounted accessories made it a breeze, and except for all of those coolant hoses going everywhere, it was literally cake.

    When I was in, I could work 40 and figure on getting paid 45-48. The really good techs could go 50-60 in a 40-hour week. I would say I was average. But a 0.6 serpentine belt, 0.2 air filter, 0.2 wipers, 0.5 oil change, and 0.6 tire rotation / balance add up to 2.1 hours that even somebody like me could have done in about an hour flat. Drum brake jobs were another place to make bank.

    Or the infamous Neon head gasket that paid I can't remember how many hours that one of our techs could do in like 20% of the time by cheating and just raising up the head enough to slide the old gasket out and a new one in. Needless to say some came back. But nobody ever made him do it the "right" way. So he did all of the Neon head gaskets since he could beat book time by the mostest. These days he owns his own shop LOL.

  9. #19
    Site Supporter
    Join Date
    Jul 2017
    Location
    Texas
    My buddy owns his repair shop and 99% of his repairs are older vehicles. In some cases he has to find parts from junk yards. I learned that there are some parts carried on parts house books but not stocked because they are no longer made. He told me that dealer techs are clueless about older vehicles.

  10. #20
    The R in F.A.R.T RevolverRob's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Location
    Gotham Adjacent
    Find a shop that services fleet box trucks and buses. Ford used the 2v Triton V10 in the E-450/550 cabs that are were used to build box trucks, ambulances, and buses until 2019.

    If the dealer has a Fleet Sales guy, get ahold of him and ask him who does service on the fleet vehicles they sell.

    The chassis is easier to service, sharing virtually all the parts with a 3/4-ton Super Duty.

    To put it bluntly, you're dealing with a specialty vehicle, now, they haven't sold the Super Duty base the Excursion is built on since 2007 nor put the V10 in a retail vehicle since 2010. The service guys and manager on the retail side won't know what to do for you. The fleet guy can help.

    And it's not just you. Once a vehicle is out of production for ~5 years, spare parts become far more difficult to find, even with an enthusiast vehicle, and not until the vehicles reach 25 years old does the market start to pick back up for them.

User Tag List

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •