I made the drive out to visit the seller last night and brought the rifle home with me. It was as advertised, and better! It's a pristine M1 Garand that looks like it just came out of H&R in 1955. There is absolutely no pitting found anywhere on it.
He was a really nice older gentleman, a shooter that shoots competitively and is very knowledgeable about surplus firearms, particular American. Had my many questions answered promptly and fully.
I may have paid a premium for a non collectible M1, but I am very happy with my new rifle. Taking it to the range tomorrow!!