Well, I needed another holster like I needed...well, you know.
But, I realized there was a disturbance in the force since the only G17 sized JMCK holster I owned was for a 17 equipped with a light mounted on the rail...so...there was an obvious void needing filling.
Since I already have a G19 sized "George", I decided to go in a different direction and ordered a WC 2.5 with both DCC clips as well as a pair of closed soft loops for the "wide pattern".
Holster came today, (from Tony's recent sale), and as usual, the workmanship is first rate. He makes the G17 sized WC feel like a G19 sized holster, and I didn't feel the need for a wedge or pad...neither for comfort, nor tucking the slide and grip.
I don't know how he does it but I'm glad he does. And the price, imho, is a bargain...even without the sale, which I was fortunate enough to take advantage of.