“There is no growth in the comfort zone.”--Jocko Willink
"You can never have too many knives." --Joe Ambercrombie
I went into dots at the beginning of the year. I like them, ESPECIALLY shooting at extended distances. Last week I pulled the last dot off my carry pistol, not because I don't think they're a technical improvement, but because I haven't found a dot that meets my needs yet.
Specifically, I'm mounting dots on 1911s (Stacatto) and a 365XL. The problems are having are several:
1. Dots small enough to mount on slim slides have such small windows that I find them to be MUCH slower to acquire, no matter how perfect my presentation is, or how much I try to track the dot in recoil
2. The three different auto-adjust dots I tinkered with were all flawed with major light "defects" in any exterior light. I'm certain this was exclusively based on the make/model I was trying, but there was so much weirdness on those screens that it was VERY difficult to see through them and acquire the target.
3. The manual adjust dots I used had two settings - too dim to see in daylight or too bright to be used in dim/interior lighting. Setting the brightness "dim" enough to not have huge bloom/glare on the lens indoors meant the dot was invisible on light colored targets in full daylight, and very dim against light colored targets when illuminated with a handheld light.
4. I'm just not confident that any of the dots I've used are going to be there when I NEED them - thinking about unpredictable battery life, unpredictable response to climate conditions, etc
At this point, I'm too cheap to do what would probably solve these issues - and buy ACROs/RMRs/SROs. Fortunately, my eyesight, while failing somewhat, is still plenty good for me to do what I need to at the 25 yard line, so I'm OK with irons.
I want red dots on everything now. Glocks, eventually my SD9VE, pellet guns, the spray nozzle on the garden hose. Everything.