The MHS is as big as pistol purchases get and that specified the DPP footprint.
Your prediction is exactly what SIG did but not in the way you meant. SIG’s removable hood on the Romeo 2 not being a true closed emitter is likely an artifact of the impracticality of mixing closed emitter optics and top mounted screws as used in SIGs existing footprint. However they are on the wrong side of history on this.