Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 123 LastLast
Results 11 to 20 of 26

Thread: DFM/X - DryFireMag combined with MantisX

  1. #11
    Site Supporter dontshakepandas's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2014
    Location
    Dallas, TX
    This is an interesting idea and can save you some coin over buying them separately, but you do give up the ability to use the Mantis X for live fire.

    I have both products separately, and like both. I keep my Mantis X on my training gun for dry fire and live fire. If I had to choose, I'd rather have the Mantis X for live and dry fire, than only for dry fire + the dry fire mag.

  2. #12
    Member
    Join Date
    Feb 2016
    Location
    Louisiana
    As someone else stated before I'll probably take heat for this, but I can't see spending money on the Mantis or Dry fire mag. I did spend (waste) the money for the nice steel frame SIRT about 2 years ago. It did not take long to see that it wasn't much of a help. I will not be getting and more dry fire "toys" in my USPSA journey.

    This is not meant to sound like a smart Alex (as Dad used to say), but the front sight will tell you what you are doing in dry fire if you actually pay attention to it. Where the bullets are impacting will do the same in live fire. At first I did not get this. The more I learn the more I see it so it may just be where you are at along the path. Just thought I'd throw this out there as I've seen a couple of guys buy the Mantis but have not seen significant improvement in their shooting. It really comes down to how much work you put in and how much focus you place on that work.

  3. #13
    Site Supporter dontshakepandas's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2014
    Location
    Dallas, TX
    Quote Originally Posted by Slalom.45 View Post
    As someone else stated before I'll probably take heat for this, but I can't see spending money on the Mantis or Dry fire mag. I did spend (waste) the money for the nice steel frame SIRT about 2 years ago. It did not take long to see that it wasn't much of a help. I will not be getting and more dry fire "toys" in my USPSA journey.

    This is not meant to sound like a smart Alex (as Dad used to say), but the front sight will tell you what you are doing in dry fire if you actually pay attention to it. Where the bullets are impacting will do the same in live fire. At first I did not get this. The more I learn the more I see it so it may just be where you are at along the path. Just thought I'd throw this out there as I've seen a couple of guys buy the Mantis but have not seen significant improvement in their shooting. It really comes down to how much work you put in and how much focus you place on that work.
    The Mantis won't make you a better shooter by itself, but it can provide data that can help you accomplish goals. For example, the new draw analysis breaks down your draw into different stages such as how long to grip, pull, break the shot etc. This can be helpful if you are trying to go faster but aren't sure where you need to shave time off.

    If all you are doing is dicking around with it and having it grade your shots, it won't provide anything that your front sight/dot won't do. If you are focused on the work it can be helpful though.

    It also works pretty well as a shot timer and keeps a keeps a history of your times/drills that you can reference to see how you are improving.

  4. #14
    Member DMF13's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2014
    Location
    Nomad
    Quote Originally Posted by dontshakepandas View Post
    For example, the new draw analysis breaks down your draw into different stages such as how long to grip, pull, break the shot etc. This can be helpful if you are trying to go faster but aren't sure where you need to shave time off.
    Good point.

    The last two days I've tried out that feature. I already knew I needed to get the draw to first shot time way down. My perception was my reaction time sucked, and was making me way slow to clear my cover garment, and get my hand on the gun. My perception was also that I was just a little slow to break the shot at the end of the press out.

    What I saw from the MantisX is that my reaction time, and movement to the gun is is actually pretty good, and while I might be able to slice off a few hundredths of second there, I won't be making any huge improvements in reaction time/movement to gun. However, I also found out I'm not just a little slow breaking the shot at the end of the press out, I'm actually wasting tons of time breaking the shot at the end of the press out. So what I learned, very quickly, is that I don't need to work on reaction time much at all, but absolutely need to work on prepping the trigger better during the press out, and breaking the shot.

    While I may have eventually gotten faster through mere repetition, now I know exactly where I need to concentrate the majority of my work to help reach my goals. I don't know if that bit of knowledge alone was worth the extra $100, it sure gave me a more clear view of something I need to work out.
    _______________
    "Whom shall I send, and who will go for us?" Then I said, "Here I am. Send me." - Isaiah 6:8

  5. #15
    Member DMF13's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2014
    Location
    Nomad
    Quote Originally Posted by Eyesquared View Post
    I guess I don't see how the dryfiremag and MantisX will integrate into a training plan for those goals. I don't know what your qual course is like but most of those other goals are very gun handling-heavy, to the point where I would be almost exclusively working draws and reloads. Just my $0.02 as someone who started USPSA and got serious about dry fire last winter, shot some ~2.2s Bill drills earlier this year, and placed in the middle of B class at my first major USPSA match in February.
    I appreciate the input, and I would agree that gun handling is a HUGE part of what I need to work on. However, I also know that my trigger control needs work, and the weak spots in trigger control are magnified the faster I try to go. So in addition to breaking the shot, I can now work on reset prep, for complete and proper follow through. That's where the Dry Fire Mag will hopefully pay off. Time will tell.

    Aside from what I've seen about the draw to first shot data (see my post above), I'm also not sure if the MantisX will do much for me, but I thought I'd try it out and see.
    _______________
    "Whom shall I send, and who will go for us?" Then I said, "Here I am. Send me." - Isaiah 6:8

  6. #16
    Site Supporter dontshakepandas's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2014
    Location
    Dallas, TX
    For anybody who does have a Mantis-X, they've added some "Marksmanship Courses" to their app and will send you actual patches if you complete them.

    I didn't find either of them too challenging, but it was a nice motivation to have a task to complete every day. Sending out the patches is pretty cool too.

    I hope they add more features like that in the future, with or without the patches.

  7. #17
    Member DMF13's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2014
    Location
    Nomad
    After three weeks with the DFM/X I thought I’d offer an update, both on the device itself, and some things I need to work on while I can’t go do any live fire.

    The DFM/X:
    1- I’m not sure if the MantisX really has any value other than the holster draw analysis. As I said previously, it has showed me where I really need to work to shave time off my draw to first shot. The holster draw timer will only give you info about your first trigger pull, so even if you try to dry fire a drill like a Bill Drill or FAST, you’re only going to get time of the first shot, and not a breakdown of your dry fire splits. Unfortunately the time only has a start beep, and no ability to have a par time stop beep.

    2- After the first 100 or so trigger pulls, I noticed the “wall” at the trigger break has gone away, and now the pull feels much more like my Glock Gen5 trigger. Hopefully it’s just something that needs to “break in,” and isn’t a harbinger of problems to come where I’ve been wearing on a part that will simply break.

    3- The “click” at reset is just as loud as the “click” for the trigger break, so this might be a problem if using an external shot timer for dry fire. I don’t know for sure, as I don’t have my own shot timer, and don’t have access to the one at work right now. However, since the sound is exactly the same to my ear, I don’t see how a shot timer would be able to distinguish between the two shots, and would likely register the reset as another shot.

    4- While the Dry Fire Mag is not as nice a 17R, especially since you can’t do reload drills with it, it is only $100 ($200 with the MantisX option), as opposed to $500 for a 17R. So you get a resetting trigger, which is easier to adjust the trigger pull weight, at relatively low cost. I’m not sure if that holster draw analysis is worth the $100, but like I’ve said it sure clued me into something I might not have figured out on my own, or at least not quickly.


    Side note about my equipment, not specific to the DFM/X:
    My practice gun is a 19 Gen4, and it has the crappy Glock plastic sights, my work gun has the Ameriglo “Agent” sights. Rather than go through the trouble and expense of adding matching sights to my dry fire pistol, I’ve painted the white front dot orange, and blacked out most of the rear white U, leaving two white dots. I figure that’s close enough to the real deal sights for dry fire work.



    Things I’m working on:
    1- In addition to the current world events keeping me from live fire, my personal and professional life for the past year and a half have kept me from doing much live fire, other than our quarterly weapons quals, and I had slacked off a lot on dry fire. Further the the other methods of dry fire were inadequate in my opinion, which is why I went looking for a 17R back in October. As a result of being busy, and a little lazy about training, my skills have deteriorated.

    2- First, about two years ago, in live fire, 7 yards, untucked shirt for concealment, I was consistently able to do a sub-1.5 second draw to first shot into our head shot target at work, with a PR of 1.1 seconds. Now I’m struggling to be consistently below 1.8 seconds in dry fire. 1.1 to 1.5 isn’t very impressive, but my times now totally suck. I’m hoping to not just get back to the a sub 1.5s, but I figure to reach my stated goals, I’m going to need get that down to consistently 1.2 seconds or better.

    3- Before getting the data on my draw to first shot times from the MantisX, I thought I was just a little slow on the press out, and a lot slow on reaction time/hand speed to getting on the gun in the holster. Turns out from buzzer, clearing my shirt, and putting my hand on the gun, I’m pretty consistent at around .45 seconds, but I’m wasting HUGE amounts of time on the press out, and on pulling the trigger at the end of the press out.

    4- Another problem I realized is that due to the previous draw, fire, re-rack, practice I had been doing, I am occasionally holding the trigger back, and “forgetting” to reset for a split second. I don’t know if was doing that recently in live fire, but with the “resetting” trigger in dry fire I now occasionally have a delay resetting the trigger . I need to work on doing a proper reset/prep for every shot.

    5- Finally, in just the last couple of weeks, because I was now conscious of just how much time I was wasting on breaking the shot at the end of the press out, I had started to get on the trigger WAY too early. I realized I need to make sure I’ve already started transitioning my eyes from target focused to front sight focused before moving my finger off the frame.

    As a result of all that, for the last 3 days I’ve slowed everything way down, and I’ve been working on smoothly doing the draw, press out, breaking the shot, reset/prep, and doing a few follow up shots, again with the proper reset/prep. Included in all that, I’m working on being sure I’ve started the press out, and have moved my focus to the front sight, before moving my finger to the trigger. My new short term goal is to do several hundred “perfect” reps over this week, before trying to speed things back up.
    Right now I’ve slowed it down to where I’m taking 2 to 2.2 seconds to break the shot. The odd thing was there were times where I wasn’t trying to go fast, but would look at the data, and have a handful of reps with times to first shot of 1.4s or less.

    After I’ve started to rebuild good habits, and can get that time down below 1.5s consistently I’ll start working through Ben Stoeger’s Dry Fire book (I cited the wrong book in my first post). Hopefully, by the time I’m through that whole book, I will also have shaved some more time off my draw to first shot. I’m also hoping the social distancing restrictions will have eased up, so I can do some live fire to see what if any benefit all the dry fire will have.
    _______________
    "Whom shall I send, and who will go for us?" Then I said, "Here I am. Send me." - Isaiah 6:8

  8. #18
    Member
    Join Date
    Sep 2018
    Location
    Eastern N.C.
    OP,

    I appreciate you starting this thread and following up periodically.

    Keith

  9. #19
    Member DMF13's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2014
    Location
    Nomad
    A bit of an update. Due to some unusual work and family demands, I trained very little for several weeks in May and June. I still haven't had access to a range for live fire, but hope to change that soon.

    However, after I slowed things down for a bit, and cleaned up some bad habits, when I started going for speed again my average draw to first shot times have gotten a tiny bit faster, but a lot more consistent. Gone are the occasional 1.8 to 2.0 fumbles, but gone also are the occasional fast but very sloppy 1.0 to 1.1 times. I'm now averaging 1.54, with times ranging from 1.35 to 1.65. Obviously I'm not happy that I'm still that slow, but I think consistency is a good thing.

    I cut my reaction time, from beep to hand on the gun, down to .37-.4 and doubt I could get much faster there. I'm going to need to get the rest of the process smoother and faster to shave off another .3 to .4 in total time. I thought I'd have the draw time down where I wanted by now, but I'm committed to getting that fixed before moving on to other things. I'm anxious to get to a live range and see how all this dry fire will translate to the real world.
    _______________
    "Whom shall I send, and who will go for us?" Then I said, "Here I am. Send me." - Isaiah 6:8

  10. #20
    Member DMF13's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2014
    Location
    Nomad
    Another update, if anyone still cares.

    I have only been doing 2 or 3 dry fire sessions a week, the last couple of months, unlike when I first started, and was doing 5 days a week. Work and family commitments, plus a renewed emphasis on quality exercise, have cut into my time for other activities.

    So far I haven't had a chance to get to a range, to run drills with a timer, but I did fire our agency qualification a week ago. There are time limits, but they aren't challenging enough to show any real difference in performance.

    On the qualification course, I've consistently been a 95+% shooter for years, and I know the reason I'm not consistently banging out 100% is trigger control. Which really shows up at the 25 yard line, where I usually throw one or two shots.

    Despite having not done any live fire for 8 months, I shot 100% a week ago, which actually surprised me. Despite the months of dry fire, I was concerned with such a long break from live fire, and thought I would struggle at the 25 yard line, but it was not an issue at all. I would have liked to have been faster (subjective feel as I wasn't on timer, just limited by the generous course times), and would have liked to have tighter groups overall, but despite the long break in live fire, I still didn't throw a single round at the 25 yard line.

    Which brings me to this, I think I benefitted greatly from the Dry Fire Mag (DFM), compared to the previous methods I was using for dry fire. Having actually been able to practice the reset/prep, in dry fire, made me much more consistent in my follow through in live fire.

    I will note, I think my plan of using the slightly heavier trigger pull on the DFM paid off. It just felt easier to quickly, but smoothly pull the trigger, when the pull weight as a little lower in live fire.

    Based on my earlier experience, I'd still prefer using a Glock 17R, but the DFM was immediately available, and at a fraction of the cost of the 17R. By the way, it's been almost a year, and I'm still waiting for the 17R I ordered. I will also say, that now I regret spending money, and time, on a SIRT, and should have just gone with this years ago. Like I said earlier, I know many will disagree, but for me the SIRT did not help.

    However, I'm not sure the integrated MantisX is really worth the extra $100. I do like the "Holster Draw Analysis," but I'm not sure that feature alone justifies the additional expense.
    _______________
    "Whom shall I send, and who will go for us?" Then I said, "Here I am. Send me." - Isaiah 6:8

User Tag List

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •