Okay, I got it out the other night. It’s a 4 x D cell Maglite with the Malkof conversion. Also took out the 6P LEGO and an SF Fury.
Bottom line, both of the smaller lights were notably better.
I focused the Maglite so there was no “dark spot” in the middle of the hotspot. So configured, it was decent out to about 50 yds, but really lacked the throw and the intensity of the other lights. The Maglite had nice spill, but no better than the others.
Indoors, in a dark house it’s about as good as the other two.
I’d say the big advantages of the Maglite w/ the LED upgrade is the crazy-long runtime, and commonly available D cells. Tertiary advantage being its alternate use as a bludgeon if required.
I’m still glad I have it, but it’s not going to replace other lights when I want “all the lumens.”