Originally Posted by
sheepdog
First, both the XD-E and the Hellcat are 1" thick. An XD-E 2.0 needs to at the very LEAST match the latter's 11+1 magazine, and considering this pistol is 5" in height, it should be even greater. Right? A pistol this high with the capacity it has just isn't competitive in my opinion. This alone forced my hand to stay with a Shield because at least it's almost a half inch shorter with a flush magazine.
Second, SA needs to get a Shield M2.0-like grip texture in lieu of that silly "Grip-Zone".
Third, SA needs to come out with a version lacking a manual safety. Cocked & locked is nice for 1911 guys, but most DA/SA gun guys these days prefer forgoing the manual safety.
Lastly, I'm not a fan of tritium sights with no tritium in the rear. What is the point of that? I dry practice clearing my house at all times of the day and night, and I can tell you there are circumstances in which I could identify a threat without being able to align my sights as quickly as I could if there was a single tritium dot in the rear (e.g. i-Dot). I liked blacked out rears, but as long as the tritium doesn't have an outlined, it is still blacked out. They should always be serrated as well in my opinion. I had the CAP sights on a Glock and don't care for the horizontal stripe which is not as fast as an i-Dot or XS standard dot sight in my opinion.
I'm sure Ernest has done a great job making this pistol much more attractive and someone who has the money to burn should definitely buy one in spite of the shortfalls I identified (which is no fault of his for sure); but in the wake of the P365 and now the Hellcat, the XD-E was unfortunately the victim of bad timing. As a recovering Glock and M&P addict, DA/SA is still the way to go in my opinion, but not necessarily in the single stack/subcompact genre of pistols until someone make them more competitive.