I think a guns value depends on its condition and other things like desirability and availability. I just question the value for the condition of theses trade in revolvers. There is used and used/ worn out. I often see guns that are heavily used but are priced way too high. At my LGS any revolver in good condition at a reasonable price is gone in a few days. Deals are out there. I got a nice 4 pre model 10 (1948?) for $270. I bought a very nice S&W 2.5 model 19 earlier this year for $550; last week I put a very nice 4 S&W model 29-2 on layaway for $1000 bucks which I thought was a bargain for the model, barrel length, age and condition. The 29-2 has a great action and is tight. I cant wait to shoot it. I need to order wood roper stocks for it