No.
The Big 3 have been in business continually since the 18th and 19th centuries. A Lange started in the '90s.
A Lange was described to me as like a beautifully finished bespoke suit. But if you removed the lining, you'll see loose threads, ragged cuts and sloppy stitching. The Patek, Audemars or Vacheron would be just as finely finished on the interior you don't see as the case and dial.
That is pretty much me, as well, for the last 24 years or so, with a few exceptions.
When I shoot, I take off my wedding ring and put on a well-used Timex Indiglo Ironman in OD/Black. I've had this Timex maybe 3 years. It is beat up but keeps perfect time.
When I need a lightweight, low visibility travel watch, I put on my other Timex Indiglo Ironman in Blue/Black. It is what I wear when I don't, really, want to be flashy.
When I was diving (a lot) I used my Citizen Aqualand. I had it over ten years, and had it serviced regularly to replace all the seals, batteries, and verify water proofness at the Sport Diving depths I was at (max approx 130 fsw).
The only time I've not used my Citizen was on a liveaboard dive trip on the Cayman Aggressor in the 90s. On that weeklong trip, I used my sub because you know, Dive Watch and all. It performed flawlessly. It was only after the trip it occurred to me that on The Wall off Cayman, with the blue abyss dissappearing in the gloom below me to 4,000 ft, was probably not a good time to be wearing a watch that cost me four figures.
But literally every other waking moment over the last couple dozen years I've worn my sub. To work, play, fun, sports, etc. I've changed the oil in my E46 wearing it.
It has worn surprisingly well over the years. I have a few "beauty impacts" on the gold especially where I've bumped into something or other. Last service i had to get a new stem as well as a new bezel, because I had some chips. That was not cheap, gold being what it is these days.
And it still came back from Rolex looking marrrrrvelous, all bright and shiny.
So, just as an observation, if you see a Rolex and it's all nice and bright, it may be a pretty experienced watch; I know mine is.
(and in case he is monitoring this thread, I have put it in my Will to give to my son when I croak. )
While you have a point on the increased mechanical complexities of a mechanical watch, my cheap watches typically were not killed by hard impacts or the like. They normally just... stopped working. Like the one that's supposed to charge its internal battery from being exposed to light, but the battery holds only a very small charge. Or a previous watch that just stopped working and replacing the battery didn't help. At this point I have enough experience with cheaper quartz watches to not trust them at all. And I've tried the inexpensive Seiko mechanical route as well, and that did not go well either. So personally, when someone says a cheap watch is "just as good" as a more expensive one, I disagree with that. I at least hope that the more expensive ones are not going to go tits up in a few years, get tossed into garbage, and end up in a landfill while the next piece of cheap Chinese junk takes its place.
Still though, what you said about your U2 was both disappointing and concerning news to me. If possible, I would be interested in hearing more about how much beating has the watch taken and what were its limits.
Any recent experiences with Ares watches? I've got my eye on a quartz Diver 1.
”But in the end all of these ideas just manufacture new criminals when the problem isn't a lack of criminals.” -JRB
”But in the end all of these ideas just manufacture new criminals when the problem isn't a lack of criminals.” -JRB
This is timely as I recently got a promotion and my open water certification. In celebration I was considering buying myself a new dive watch. I daily wear a Seiko SKX007 but it needs service (gains substantial time daily and I have to reset the time most mornings) and I was also looking for something a little higher end. Rolex and Omega are out of my price range.
I was considering either the Ares Diver-1 or a Marathon GSAR. I was leaning toward the Ares but in looking at reviews via Google see a lot of people calling out QC issues. I know people usually only post the problems though and not good experiences.
Anyone have noteworthy QC or CS issues?