Originally Posted by
GJM
My timmie instincts draw me to Carry Optics, and here is why.
With a long gun, except in very special circumstances, I believe that it is well established that an optic, whether red dot or scope, is a better solution than iron sights. The reason the red dot is not at the same place on a pistol is part technique and part technology. The technology is fixing to change with the Acro, and my CO experience tells me that I have overcome the technique challenges of using a dot.
Two and a half years ago, I was shooting a Shadow 1 in Production and enjoying it, with the caveat that I wished I was not competing with a gun that I would never carry. I got a G19 MOS to evaluate a red dot again. Initially, I thought it made me more visual, and helped my iron sight shooting. Then I realized I could shoot the 19 better than my Shadow, because of the addition of the dot. That got me shooting CO, and with the rule change to 140mm magazines, it allowed me to shoot stages with more focus on shootng than reloading.
I still see iron sights well enough to shoot small groups at 25 yards, but that is in good light. Even still, my ability to shift my focus from front sight to target to front sight is not the same as when I was 20. If I am lucky enough to do this for many more years, normal aging will make that visual focus shift more problematic. The red dot allows me to be competitive with the kind of gun I actually carry, offers me more EDC tactical capability in dim light or on a moving target, and takes away vision as a competitive factor when shooting against twenty year olds.
This afternoon, late in my practice session, I pulled out the G19/RMR I carried to the range, and with that combination, I can shoot a very high percentage of my performance with my full on CO pistol. Besides the speed stuff, I can easily put ten shots into a 3x5 at 25 yards, even in weird light. This allows all the effort I put into gaming to completely transfer to my timmie gun and ability!