I would suggest if you are serious about aiwb you start out with a purpose built holster. It will cost more but yield better results, more comfort, better concealment etc. If you want a clip model I would highly suggest the clip Dark Star Gear offers. I messed around with that clip the first day I got it by not wearing a belt and just clipping it on my jeans. Not only did it not pop off after multiple draws but I actually had to undo my jeans to get it off the first time lol. I've either broken or had plastic clips pop off of my belt. I don't find the wide fomi style clips to be comfortable either. Short barrels don't work well for me either so I would go with a long holster for sure.