Purely conjecture, but looking around online I found more than a couple folks stating the 26 might be a bit over sprung,
they use the same rsa in the 27 and 33.
So maybe, you were seeing a combination of lack of slide velocity + either a too weak/ or strong mag spring in the 17, causing timing issues. Or maybe there’s enough play in the longer mag that you to force it into the slide and slow things down just enough to not work?