I'm with you there on the durability of the finish, insert "these are tools!" comment to which I also agree. I enjoy the look of a well-worn used pistol, that being said if the longevity of the finish is a concern I'd advocate going with that aftermarket finish. My Brig Tac doesn't have the greatest of finishes on the grasping grooves on the rear of the slide but truthfully I don't think much of it. In time as the whole gun begins to show some wear and I don't want to look at it any longer that's probably when I'll explore the refinishing options.