I usually find it harder to hit the right level of 'done' with a reverse sear. So I like to have several cooks with a steak doing the traditional sear under my belt before trying a reverse sear. I've done enough ribeyes and filets from Costco and Randall's I'm comfortable doing them with a reverse sear.
Knowing the tomahawk wasn't enough for 3 I also cooked a dry aged ribeye as well and nailed medium rare and we all preferred that. Less $ and aggravation, think I'll stick to the dry aged ribeyes. I think only the dog will be disappointed.