I exclusively use aluminum NHMTG.
I wouldn't give up on BCM just yet, Paul Buffoni has always been a good guy in my book. If I were in your shoes, I'd put my complaint on paper, mail it to BCM and ask that it gets forwarded to Paul. See what happens, the worst case scenario is that you get told no.
Please check your PM's when you have a chance. I might be able to assist.
Thanks, and stay safe.
Sionics weapon systems has been getting some pretty good reviews over at M4C, with some pretty knowledgable folks endorsing or working with them. They're from my state, and pretty competitively priced for a mil-spec lower. I'll be picking one up next month to use on my BCM upper, but I don't have any first hand experience with them yet. May be worth looking into.
- Cole
I bought a Sionics complete lower to go with my BCM upper. Seems just fine, price was right and it came with the VLTOR A5 system and ALG QMS trigger. Happy with it so far but the rifle's only got a couple hundred rounds through it at this point. Haven't tried any Gen3 PMAGs either.
"Customer is very particular" -- SIG Sauer
My favorite plastic mags for the AR are the TangoDown ARC mags. They fit and function in every lower I've tried, including BCM and a friend's no-name lower that would not run PMAGs. I ran them through a course several years ago, pouring rain for two days; a real mudbath. TD's worked great, even covered in mud.
I assume you are talking about the Mk2 ARC mags. The mk 2's seem to be GTG, however I had serious issues with the original ARC mags. They would not function in multiple colt and LMT M-4s and ARs. I mention this because there may still be some of the originals floating around.
You can always count on this one for a good chuckle!
Seriously though, I am a huge fan of MEGA. That would be my choice.
After reading this thread yesterday, I dug a couple of new gen 3 Pmags out and tried them in both a newer BCM lower and a second one of older vintage. The mags (a couple examples) fit/lockup in both. Just FWIW. I'd get ahold of Paul directly.
t