Taint that simple, IMO.
For me it's a matter of utilizing the best tool for the job. For example, I very well might choose a tight all black on black serrated combination for shooting bullseye. On the other end of the spectrum, for fast paced action shooting at speed, on the move, etc... I might choose a sight combination with a more open relationship and some sort of bright aiming reference that'll allow me to "see what I need to see" faster.
Carry/duty sights for me are always going to be a compromise b/c of the breadth of potential conditions in which they may need to be used. When you can tell me beforehand what conditions will be present when my time comes, I'll make an educated best choice. Until then, I'm going to continue to use what provides the best balance of characteristics based on *my* most likely set of needs.
t