Jody is right that it's probably better if he hangs it up, but where I worked the pension board and work comp hearing officers were not known to be generous with disability retirement packages. As an example, one guy I worked with had a heart attack and was resuscitated twice in the ER. The pension board refused his request for disability retirement. I can't see them feeling the love on a self-inflicted weak hand finger. In this case I think it's his lawyer trying to make the case for a larger award for stupidity.