I love my G-hook'd Volund Atlas. The Shaggy fits the Atlas well; some people complain that the the Shaggy's loop is too thick. The Keeper belt loop is thinner, made for the Wilderness belt, he says, and the Atlas' loops make it a bit too snug; you've got to really reef on it to get it through; it still works fine, once you've pulled it through. There's no way of making everyone happy.