Well...I hope he answers all these questions. ..seriously curious!
Based on many, many years of bird hunting and sporting clays with both spaghetti guns mentioned......
It's my opinion that Beretta's have noticeably less perceived recoil. Also, it's been my experience that Beretta guns are more reliable with low recoil ammo. BOTH guns run great when they're dirty, but the Benelli has a very slight advantage operating in adverse weather conditions.
Sorry for the late answer, I totaled 60.000 rds in roughly five years. because of cost I shot mainly birdshots on steel, roughly 10.000 rds of slugs and maybe another 10.000 buckshots. My personal M4 held really well, I switched the original stock with a full stock, shortened to 13 inches LOP. As a matter of fact I didn't experience any breakage, but I guess that a stedy diet of only buckshot and slugs would had different impact on the gun. I used exclusively fiocchi ammo (again due to cost) I owned it from 2001 to 2006 I never babied it (back then I was a little cro-magnon with guns..) cleaned every 1000 rds, I shot roughly 200 to 500 rds every week, steadily, sorry but I never care to inspect wear points, but, nothing breaked in the timeframe. I sold the gun in 2006 to a friend, he still has it, and it's still going going strong. With the 28 gr. birdshot I had the occasional failure to eject but never with 32 gr. watch out however for the picatinny rail, it's not a real picatinny, I used an aimpoint M2 on it, and even when the factory mount was tightened real good it had some very slight wobble. I used a thin shim on mount and it held well. Also loctite EVERYTHING that can be loctited, because it WILL fall out.. I lost two screws from the picatinny even using blue loctite, and had to use red loctite on rear sight screws.
Good info, thanks! Not often you get wear-point/failure data over 60K rounds on something like this.
Thank you.
Question: does the collapsible stock work well in this capacity or does the cheek position get too high to use the sights?
-------------------------------------
"One cannot awaken a man who pretends to be asleep."