Should You Talk to the Police After a Self-Defense Incident? (Part I)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7RCn...em-uploademail

I didn't watch the video, but I am in completely agreement with @Mas 's take on it. Interestingly, we arrived at the same conclusion independently, although of course I'm sure he'd figured it out long before I was in a position to.

In a nutshell, you probably want to give a limited statement that establishes you were the victim, where evidence that might disappear or be overlooked is, and who witnesses are before they move on, and if any additional suspects are still out (say you shot one and another escaped and stole a car to flee the scene). Once you've established that, shut up.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BehindBlueI's

I didn't watch the video, but I am in completely agreement with @Mas 's take on it. Interestingly, we arrived at the same conclusion independently, although of course I'm sure he'd figured it out long before I was in a position to.

In a nutshell, you probably want to give a limited statement that establishes you were the victim, where evidence that might disappear or be overlooked is, and who witnesses are before they move on, and if any additional suspects are still out (say you shot one and another escaped and stole a car to flee the scene). Once you've established that, shut up.

---

What is a good way to shut up at that point? This is not a criticism, but a request on the best way to do that?

I give Branca points for his spread collar and french cuffs, and the other guy for a more quality finish to his jacket.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zincwarrior

What is a good way to shut up at that point? This is not a criticism, but a request on the best way to do that?

---

You can let the officer know that you are shaken up by the incident and your head is not completely clear. That you fully intend to cooperate as best you can after you've had some time to compose yourself and speak with an attorney.

There is no stigma in so doing and it is your right to speak to an attorney before making further, or any statements, for that matter.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by blues

You can let the officer know that you are shaken up by the incident and your head is not completely clear. That you fully intend to cooperate as best you can after you've had some time to compose yourself and speak with an attorney.

There is no stigma in so doing and it is your right to speak to an attorney before making further, or any statements, for that matter.

---

Thank you. I will tell the wife and daughter.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zincwarrior

What is a good way to shut up at that point? This is not a criticism, but a request on the best way to do that?

---

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QwM5KpoPPrg

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Wingate's Hairbrush

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QwM5KpoPPrg

---

Yeah, let's make false statements to the cops' and tie up EMS on a fake cardiac/stroke episode. I mean, you're the only person in the whole universe, so who else could possibly need EMS for a real cardiac event?
Pretty fucking stupid response.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wvincent

Yeah, let's make false statements to the cops' and tie up EMS on a fake cardiac/stroke episode. I mean, you're the only person in the whole universe, so who else could possibly need EMS for a real cardiac event?
Pretty fucking stupid response.

---

In their defense, I thought it was pretty funny and meant as such...

...And on topic, oftentimes the "experts" will tell you to be checked out by EMT's or at an ER if there is the slightest injury, wound or issue such as shortness of breath, etc. so that it is documented in the police report. Even more important if images can be taken of any wounds or injuries to bolster your side.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wvincent

Yeah, let's make false statements to the cops' and tie up EMS on a fake cardiac/stroke episode. I mean, you're the only person in the whole universe, so who else could possibly need EMS for a real cardiac event?
Pretty fucking stupid response.

---

Take a breather, pal, everything's okay -- no one's actually suggesting this is the thing to do; it was a lighthearted aside in a thread that already has some very good advice. ;)