PDA

View Full Version : Disclosing CCW to LEs?



LowAndLeft
07-22-2023, 02:29 AM
LE members, do you want to know if someone you are around for an extended period (lunch in a cafe, summer concert in a park, etc.) has a CCW? I'm asking this as I'm concerned with friendly fire if something required me to draw. I'm in CA if that matters. Thanks.

Dennis
07-22-2023, 10:44 AM
Uhhh. No. Keep it to yourself and pay attention to your surroundings. Especially in CA.

It would be a 0.00001% situation where you would need to draw when there are uniformed LE around. You need to worry more about LE you don't see if you end up in a shooting.

Your goal is to never draw. Keep your head on a swivel and avoid trouble or undue attention.

Dennis.


Sent from my SM-S908U using Tapatalk

DaBigBR
07-22-2023, 12:53 PM
Nope. Keep it to yourself.

jnc36rcpd
07-22-2023, 01:52 PM
I would agree that there is no need to disclose under those circumstances. Apart from being unnecessary, there is always the risk that you're strayed into some no-go zone from CCW which will be an inconvenience for both the LEO and you (especially you).

Problems are less likely to occur if uniform LEO's are present (though we can and do attract trouble). If something does occur, let the uniforms handle it.

Could something happen when a LEO would welcome the assistance of a CCW holder? Certainly that can and does happen, but you're no worse off than if you witnessed a similar event driving down the street rather than sitting in a cafe or at a concert.

WobblyPossum
07-22-2023, 02:37 PM
Agreed with everyone else so far. If you’re an acquaintance of mine I don’t need to know if you have a CCW if we’re hanging out at a concert or a restaurant or something. If I see you printing I might ask what you’re carrying just out of curiosity and because I like to talk about guns with other gun people. If you’re in a professional encounter with LE such as a traffic stop, then make sure you know what the laws are in your area regarding mandatory disclosure to LE. Whenever you draw a gun in public, you assume some greater-than-0% chance that you get shot by another friendly. If you’re hanging out with an LE acquaintance and they end up having to draw a gun, you can always volunteer your CCW information and see what they would like you to do but I probably wouldn’t tell them otherwise.

KevH
07-22-2023, 03:25 PM
LE members, do you want to know if someone you are around for an extended period (lunch in a cafe, summer concert in a park, etc.) has a CCW? I'm asking this as I'm concerned with friendly fire if something required me to draw. I'm in CA if that matters. Thanks.

Keep it to yourself.

The only time I would want to know is if I'm dealing with you or detaining you on a call for service. Please don't come up to me and tell me while I'm trying to eat my lunch and please don't point to your buddy and say, "He did it." :)

If there are a bunch of cops somewhere (concert, restaurant, etc.) and shooting starts don't draw and start shooting. Get yourself and your loved ones out of there.

If the cops are down and have been shot and you decide to intervene (absolute worst case scenario), then use common sense and make sure they know you are a good guy so you don't get shot. The Newhall Incident with CHP in 1970 comes to mind.

I have had an armed citizen jump in to help me before on a interrupted burglary call. I was driving to a burglary in progress call in the middle of the night when the suspect emerged from the backyard of a house a few streets over. I was by myself (everyone else was at or headed to the house he had just broken into) and challenged the guy, chased him briefly and tackled him. An alert homeowner who was getting ready to go to work heard the commotion, saw what was happening, grabbed his Beretta from his nightstand and stuck it in his waistband and jumped in to help me in the minute or two before other cops arrived. He just said, "I'm here to help you bud and and I'm armed." He helped me cuff the guy and as I caught my breathe I let everyone else know that I had a citizen helping me. No harm no foul. The guy used common sense and I was glad for the help.

He didn't have a CCW or anything, but he looked like a normal guy about to go to a job site, it was obvious what his intent was, and he had used good common sense.

Common sense is the operative phrase here.

Hambo
07-22-2023, 06:31 PM
LE members, do you want to know if someone you are around for an extended period (lunch in a cafe, summer concert in a park, etc.) has a CCW? I'm asking this as I'm concerned with friendly fire if something required me to draw. I'm in CA if that matters. Thanks.

If something happens that causes you to think about pulling a gun, there will be three groups that might kill you: LEOs, bad guys, and other heroes.

jandbj
07-22-2023, 08:12 PM
In addition to the above post.

Car stops & incidental contacts… keep the hands where I can see them and just tell me you have a carry permit and are armed. I’ll tell you how to proceed from there.

Social situations : don’t ask, don’t tell, don’t print.

Kyle Reese
07-23-2023, 08:18 AM
In addition to the above post.

Car stops & incidental contacts… keep the hands where I can see them and just tell me you have a carry permit and are armed. I’ll tell you how to proceed from there.

Social situations : don’t ask, don’t tell, don’t print.

This.

Casey
07-24-2023, 07:32 PM
Car stops & incidental contacts… keep the hands where I can see them and just tell me you have a carry permit and are armed. I’ll tell you how to proceed from there.
My perspective, unless required by law to notify (which isn't the case here in Florida), I'm not volunteering anything unless specifically asked if I am armed. The last time I was pulled over while carrying (circa 2009), I did notify the officer, who then opted to remove my gun from my ankle holster and unload it and the magazine before returning it to me and letting me go. That's a whole lot of unnecessary administrative gun-handling and while some cops might be gun guys, many are not, and I'd just as soon the gun stay securely and safely in the holster.

DaBigBR
07-25-2023, 03:38 AM
I honestly don't even want to know you're carrying on a traffic stop unless your version of "carrying" is the gun is in your glove box keeping your insurance card from blowing away. If it becomes important to me, I'm going to ask you if you're armed or I'm just going to pat you down.

Magsz
07-26-2023, 05:06 PM
In addition to the above post.

Car stops & incidental contacts… keep the hands where I can see them and just tell me you have a carry permit and are armed. I’ll tell you how to proceed from there.

Social situations : don’t ask, don’t tell, don’t print.

State Statute will dictate that. Not all states are a duty to inform State.

I assume everyone is carrying. I am appreciative when people tell me they are armed but I assume everyone is. Even more so now that we have constitutional carry here in Florida.

fixer
07-26-2023, 05:14 PM
Some states are “ duty to inform” during a formal interaction with police that requires the rendering of identification.

During a social interaction it is no different then any other social interaction: blabbering on about your carry piece is a rookie and immature move that will only cause 300x more problems than you bargain for… especially in 2023.

wsr
07-26-2023, 05:52 PM
I usually do the FBI credential flip (as seen on any number of tv shows…if you’re not familiar) and announce in a command voice “ WSR…CPL holder, I got your back if shit goes sideways”

They seem to really appreciate it

Tex41mag
07-26-2023, 06:17 PM
Here in Texas, if you are carrying concealed and hold a Texas Concealed Handgun License, you must present the CHL when stopped and declare that you are carrying a concealed weapon. If not you could have your CHL taken away thus also removing many privileges that come along with having one. Texas now has permit less carry so presenting the CHL is not required since it is not required. If I am stopped for any reason I always hand the LEO my identification with the CHL on top.