2000 Round Revolver Challenge

[Flashman]

Let's see if revolvers can hold up as well as semi-auto pistols to Todd's 2000 Round Challenge rules?

* The pistol cannot be cleaned, lubricated, or maintained in any way during the entire 2,000 round test period. *

[NPV]

I don’t think it will happen. My J’s start choking before 600 rounds.

[Lester Polfus]

You go first...

[Duelist]

My S&W 18 might make 100 rounds before coking up too much to continue. There is ammo that will do it in two cylinders. Twelve rounds, two shots per chamber.

Most any of my others will do better than that, but they aren’t Glocks.

[BehindBlueI's]

Let's see if revolvers can hold up as well as semi-auto pistols to Todd's 2000 Round Challenge rules?

They can't. Especially if you aren't allowing things like sweeping out flakes of unburnt powder under the extractor.

[Stephanie B]

Let's see if revolvers can hold up as well as semi-auto pistols to Todd's 2000 Round Challenge rules?

* The pistol cannot be cleaned, lubricated, or maintained in any way during the entire 2,000 round test period. *

I see no reason to do this, or to abuse any of my guns in such a way.

[PNWTO]

Maybe a 500 or 750 round challenge? Or just 250?

Or maybe simply surviving an afternoon with jetfire?

[serialsolver]

I had a Brazilian contract 1917 that did an informal 2000 round challenge. After 500 or so rounds I would pull a bore snake thru the barrel and chambers a couple of times but yeah I believe it would complete a 2000 round challenge.

I’m also confident any of my ruger single action center fired revolvers would complete a 2000 round challenge.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[Trooper224]

Easy answer: they won't.

[Totem Polar]

I don’t remember what the round count is in ECQC. It’s not very high. Revolvers will do that.

[03RN]

Id think it would depend on the load. Most factory ammo is pretty clean, same with my jacketed reloads. Cast ammo is dirty and i definitely dont think it would do it

[Rick R]

I can’t wrap my brain around firing 2,000 rounds thru any handgun without any periodic maintenance. I could see firing 2,000 rounds using your chosen PM / cleaning schedule to test both the weapon AND your abilities to be a gun owner.

[Doc_Glock]

Did this in 2018. Almost made it. Won’t do it again. If I had put locktite on that screw at the beginning it would have made it no sweat.

Pistol: Ruger LCR 9mm

Caliber: 9mm

Ammunition: Wolf 115 grain Mil Spec
Barnaul 115 grain white box
Wolf 115 grain poly coat
Fiocchi 115 grain FMJ
S&B 115 grain FMJ SB9A
S&B 124 grain FMJ SB9B
Federal HST 147 grain
American Eagle 147 grain FMJ
Speer Lawman 147 grain FMJ
Speer Lawman 124 grain FMJ
Speer Lawman 115 grain FMJ
Winchester Ranger T +P 124 grain
Magtech 115 grain FMJ
Magtech 124 grain FMJ

Dates of testing: 8/2018

Total rounds fired: 2015

Stoppages: 5 light strikes on steel ammo, 1 light strike Speer Lawman 115 grain. All fired second strike.

Malfunctions: On round 1985 this happened:

https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20180828/8e296213e00ef53531489173ee2fb228.jpg

First the pivot pin fell out, then the cylinder release fell out. The gun still fired the last cylinder but I needed some tools to get the release and pin back in to open it. Took about 5 minutes to figure it out. Fired the last 30 rounds uneventfully.

Breakages: 0

It is a great, reliable revolver. I abused this gun heavily. Many times the cylinder was too hot to handle on reloads. Nearly perfect reliability. If I had checked screws for looseness more often it would have been a perfect run. It didn’t like Russian steel case but had no difficulty lighting off really hard S&B primers. I am unsure why it had a problem with the 115 grain Speer round, but that is the same ammo that gave my Langdon LTT 92 some fits.

I am unaware of any attempted 2k challenges with a revolver and had previously thought revolvers to be a bit fragile. My thoughts have been changed by this gun.

I found it to be extremely accurate when I did my part (which was not easy) and capable of printing 3-4" groups at 25 yards.

I am unsure what to do with it, as it does not really fit a carry niche for me and it is unpleasant to shoot. Thinking about getting a larger grip for it. But is is absolutely reliable.

Pros: Great ballistics, great reliability, light weight, reliable extraction and relatively quick reloads with moon clips
Cons: Snappy recoil, difficult but not impossible to shoot well, kinda big and possibly a little heavy for the pocket, low capacity.

[Dagga Boy]

And this is done, because it’s bubble gum level forum stuff. Never made to be shot 2000 rounds without cleaning, lubrication or maintenance and nobody with any level of sense would advocate for it. I have bunches of revolvers that have well over 2000 rounds through them.