I have 2 watches currently: Cheap and cheaper. Daily wear is a $20 Casio Quartz plastic thing from Wal-mart. Works like a champ. Hands have luminescent paint that you can load with a flashlight, but otherwise is not visible in dark.
Dress is an Invicta, black with black bracelet. Bracelet shows heavy wear on the bottom from rubbing on desk typing on keyboard (used to work an office job).
My wife asked me about my annual combo birthday/fathers day/anniversary gift and I mentioned I'd like a nice watch. More utility than dress I think, but something that could go either way. Thinking stainless. I'd like it to either have a button I could push to light it up or tritium so it would glow all the time to be able to tell time in the dark. I used to work in a gun shop that was a Luminox stocking dealer, so I guess that's where the thought comes from.
Stylistically, this appeals to me: