Originally Posted by
SLG
I run NF on almost all my long guns. There is no tougher scope, period. The 1-4 is tougher than any of the scopes you listed. There are no "flaws" with it whatsoever. Its limitations come from being a 4X, but if you don't need more magnification, that's not a flaw. The illum isn't a real daylight option, but as you mentioned, its not really needed. I keep it on so that when I go indoors I can still use it. None of the 1-6's or 1-8's are as light and well balanced. Some of them have a nicer picture due to more modern glass prescriptions, but I don't find the NXS compacts to be bad in that regard.
Also, and though this is less important on the 1-4 compared to the more LR oriented optics, what sets NF apart from almost everyone else is the fidelity of their turrets and reticles. When you dial a correction, you get that correction, every single time. That is much more important to precision than a nicer color picture. Though again, their newer stuff has a newer prescription and the BEAST is pretty peerless in picture as well.
NF is releasing some impressive new scopes at SHOT this year, so you might wait till then to see if something else floats your boat, but I assure you, you can't go wrong with the 1-4 on a GP carbine.
Did I make it clear that I like NF a ton?:-)